Audit working papers are the documents which record all audit evidence obtained during financial statements auditing, internal management auditing, information systems auditing, and investigations. Audit working papers are used to support the audit work done to assure that the audit was performed by the relevant auditing standards.
According to SAS 41, working papers are the records kept by the auditor of the procedures applied, the tests performed, the information obtained, and the pertinent conclusions reached in the engagement.
Working papers should include all the information the auditor considers necessary to conduct the audit adequately and to provide support for the audit report. Increasingly, working papers are maintained in computerized files.
Importance of Working Papers
Working papers are an essential part of every audit for effectively planning the audit, providing a record of the evidence accumulated and the results of the tests, deciding the proper type of audit report, and reviewing the work of assistants.
CPA firms establish their policies and approaches for working paper preparation to make sure that these objectives are met.
High-quality CPA firms make sure that working papers are properly prepared and are appropriate for the circumstances in the audit. Working papers are important because:
- Working papers assist in the planning and performance of the audit.
- Working papers are necessary for audit quality control purposes.
- Working papers assure that the work delegated by the audit partner has been properly completed.
- Working papers provide evidence that an effective audit has been carried out.
- Working papers increase the economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of the audit.
- Working papers contain sufficiently detailed and up-to-date facts which justify the reasonableness of the auditor’s conclusions.
- Working papers retain a record of matters of continuing significance to future audits.
- The preparation of the working papers is a means to give training to the audit clerks as to how to summarize the work done by them.
- The working papers enable the auditor to point out to the client the weakness of the internal control system in operation and inefficiency of the accountancy system. He may, therefore, be in a position to advise his client as to how to avoid such pitfalls.
- The working papers enable the auditor to prepare the report to be issued without much waste of time.
- He can know that his assistants had followed his instructions.
Contents of Working Papers
Each audit working paper must be headed with the following information:
- The name of the client
- The period covered by the audit
- The subject matter
- The file reference
- The initials (signature) of the member of staff who prepared the working paper, and the date on which it was prepared
- In the case of audit papers prepared by client staff, the date the working papers were received, and the initials of the audit team member who carried out the audit work
- The initials of the member of staff who reviewed the working papers and the date on which the review was carried out.
Characteristics of Good Working Papers
Based on the discussion above, a good, working paper should meet the requirements of ISA 230 by displaying the following characteristics:
- Working papers should contain all the essential information so that they may be of maximum utility. Facts that are not important should be omitted.
- It should state a clear audit objective, usually in terms of an audit assertion (for example, ‘to ensure the completeness of trade creditors’).
- It should fully state the year/period end (e.g. 31 October 2006), so that the .working paper is not confused with documentation belonging to a different year/period.
- It should state the full extent of the test (i.e. how many items were tested and how this number was determined). This will enable the preparer and any subsequent reviewers, to determine the sufficiency of the audit evidence provided by the working paper.
- Where there is a necessary reference to another working paper, the full reference for that other working paper must be given. A statement that details of testing can be found on ‘another working paper’ is insufficient.
- The working paper should clearly and objectively state the results of the test, without bias, and based on the facts documented.
- The conclusions reached should be consistent with the results of the test and should be able to withstand independent scrutiny.
- The working paper should be referenced so that it can be filed appropriately and found easily when required at a later date.
- It should be signed by the person who prepares it so that queries can be directed to the appropriate person.
- It should be signed and dated by any person who reviews it, to meet the quality control requirements of the review.
- The paper used for working papers should be of good quality so that by frequent handling, it may not be damaged.
- Paper used should be of convenient and uniform size.
- Sufficient space should be left after each note so that any decision taken by the auditor may be taken down in that space.
Ownership of Working Papers
The working papers prepared during the engagement, including those prepared by the client for the auditor, are the property of the auditor. The only time anyone else, including the client, has a legal right to examine the papers is when they are subpoenaed by a court as legal evidence.
After the engagement, working papers and computer files are retained on the CPA’s premises for future reference. Many firms follow the practice of microfilming hard copy working papers after several years to reduce storage costs.
Responsibility, Protection, and Preservation of Working Papers
Whosoever has working papers should be responsible for their safe custody. They should in no case be shown to a third party except with the permission of the client.
After the audit report has been prepared and delivered to the client, these papers- may be filed and preserved for a period of five to ten years or even more.